InfoVis:Wiki - User contributions [en]

VisWeek V&V

2011-11-01T16:36:56Z

Lebot:

At [[VisWeek 2011]], Robert M. Kirby, Claudio T. Silva, Robert S. Laramee, and William Schroeder participated in a panel entitled "Verification in Visualization: Building a Common Culture"

The slides used during the panel:

* Mike Kirby: [[Image:KirbyVisPanel2011.pdf]]
* Claudio
* Bob [http://cs.swan.ac.uk/~csbob/research/panel/laramee11verification.pdf]
* William Schroeder

The panel was recorded and will be available at http://vgtc.org/ "soon"

Inspired by the discussions at this panel, the following people would like to organize an effort to facilitate V&V at future VisWeek submissions:

* Britta Weber
* Tim Lebo
* Carlos Scheidegger
* (feel free to add your name)

A few of us met for lunch immediately after the panel, and discussed a few points:

* SIGMOD has had something like it for 2 years, so we can borrow their model.
* Reproducibility takes (uncredited) time and effort; producing unreproducible papers is valued by the community.
* A grad student once published make files behind every published image - but stopped when he got a job.
* Publishing your code (without an established system) provides value because people grab it, use it, remember your name, and cite you in their publications.

The following people may provide useful suggestions for how to increase reproducibility within VisWeek publications:

* Claudio T. Silva - knows about SIGMOD's effort.
* Gordon Kindlmann - was involved in Claudios efforts
* "make file" SCI student - because he cared about it enough to make make files.
* [http://www.slideshare.net/anitawaard Anita de Waard]

Some points:

* we should be careful not to confuse the two issues of V&V and reproducibility. V&V is roughly about a set of guidelines for ensuring that your code is correct; reproducibility is about making sure I can replicate your results.
* We should plan to have a decent set of guidelines in place so that if the VisWeek 2013 committee wants to use them, they can.

Related work

* http://www.executablepapers.com/ by Elsevier
* http://lemire.me/blog/archives/2010/04/20/the-mythical-reproducibility-of-science/
* http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20876290
* http://www.openscience.org/blog/?p=306
* http://www.snee.com/bobdc.blog/2011/10/publishing-academic-research-d.html

VisWeek V&V

2011-11-01T14:14:23Z

Lebot:

VisWeek V&V

2011-11-01T13:56:47Z

Lebot:

At [[VisWeek 2011]], Robert M. Kirby, Claudio T. Silva, Robert S. Laramee, and William Schroeder participated in a panel entitled "Verification in Visualization: Building a Common Culture"

The slides used during the panel:

* Mike Kirby: [[Image:KirbyVisPanel2011.pdf]]
* Claudio
* Bob [http://cs.swan.ac.uk/~csbob/research/panel/laramee11verification.pdf]
* Schroeder

The panel was recorded and will be available at http://vgtc.org/ "soon"

Inspired by the discussions at this panel, the following people would like to organize an effort to facilitate V&V at future VisWeek submissions:

* Britta Weber
* Tim Lebo
* (feel free to add your name)

A few of us met for lunch immediately after the panel, and discussed a few points:

* SIGMOD has had something like it for 2 years, so we can borrow their model.
* Reproducibility takes (uncredited) time and effort; producing unreproducible papers is valued by the community.
* A grad student once published make files behind every published image - but stopped when he got a job.
* Publishing your code (without an established system) provides value because people grab it, use it, remember your name, and cite you in their publications.

The following people may provide useful suggestions for how to increase reproducibility within VisWeek publications:

* Claudio T. Silva - knows about SIGMOD's effort.
* Gordon Kindlmann - was involved in Claudios efforts
* "make file" SCI student - because he cared about it enough to make make files.
* [http://www.slideshare.net/anitawaard Anita de Waard]

Related work

* http://www.executablepapers.com/ by Elsevier
* http://lemire.me/blog/archives/2010/04/20/the-mythical-reproducibility-of-science/
* http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20876290
* http://www.openscience.org/blog/?p=306

VisWeek V&V

2011-10-31T18:38:31Z

Lebot:

At [[VisWeek 2011]], Robert M. Kirby, Claudio T. Silva, Robert S. Laramee, and William Schroeder participated in a panel entitled "Verification in Visualization: Building a Common Culture"

The slides used during the panel:

* Mike Kirby: [[Image:KirbyVisPanel2011.pdf]]
* Claudio
* Bob
* Schroeder

The panel was recorded and will be available at http://vgtc.org/ "soon"

Inspired by the discussions at this panel, the following people would like to organize an effort to facilitate V&V at future VisWeek submissions:

* Britta Weber
* Tim Lebo
* (feel free to add your name)

A few of us met for lunch immediately after the panel, and discussed a few points:

* SIGMOD has had something like it for 2 years, so we can borrow their model.
* Reproducibility takes (uncredited) time and effort; producing unreproducible papers is valued by the community.
* A grad student once published make files behind every published image - but stopped when he got a job.
* Publishing your code (without an established system) provides value because people grab it, use it, remember your name, and cite you in their publications.

The following people may provide useful suggestions for how to increase reproducibility within VisWeek publications:

* Claudio T. Silva - knows about SIGMOD's effort.
* "make file" SCI student - because he cared about it enough to make make files.
* [http://www.slideshare.net/anitawaard Anita de Waard]

Related work

* http://www.executablepapers.com/ by Elsevier
* http://lemire.me/blog/archives/2010/04/20/the-mythical-reproducibility-of-science/
* http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20876290
* http://www.openscience.org/blog/?p=306

VisWeek V&V

2011-10-31T15:24:22Z

Lebot:

At [[VisWeek 2011]], Robert M. Kirby, Claudio T. Silva, Robert S. Laramee, and William Schroeder participated in a panel entitled "Verification in Visualization: Building a Common Culture"

The slides used during the panel:

* Mike Kirby: [[Image:KirbyVisPanel2011.pdf]]
* Claudio
* Bob
* Schroeder

Inspired by the discussions at this panel, the following people would like to organize an effort to facilitate V&V at future VisWeek submissions:

* Britta Weber
* Tim Lebo
* (feel free to add your name)

A few of us met for lunch immediately after the panel, and discussed a few points:

* SIGMOD has had something like it for 2 years, so we can borrow their model.
* Reproducibility takes (uncredited) time and effort; producing unreproducible papers is valued by the community.
* A grad student once published make files behind every published image - but stopped when he got a job.
* Publishing your code (without an established system) provides value because people grab it, use it, remember your name, and cite you in their publications.

The following people may provide useful suggestions for how to increase reproducibility within VisWeek publications:

* Claudio T. Silva - knows about SIGMOD's effort.
* "make file" SCI student - because he cared about it enough to make make files.
* [http://www.slideshare.net/anitawaard Anita de Waard]

Related work

* http://www.executablepapers.com/ by Elsevier
* http://lemire.me/blog/archives/2010/04/20/the-mythical-reproducibility-of-science/
* http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20876290
* http://www.openscience.org/blog/?p=306

VisWeek V&V

2011-10-31T15:17:36Z

Lebot:

VisWeek V&V

2011-10-31T15:16:53Z

Lebot:

File:KirbyVisPanel2011.pdf

2011-10-31T15:15:37Z

Lebot: Slides by Mike Kirby for V&V panel at VisWeek 2011

== Summary ==
Slides by Mike Kirby for V&V panel at VisWeek 2011
== Copyright status ==
can share
== Source ==
Mike Kirby

VisWeek V&V

2011-10-31T15:03:54Z

Lebot:

At [[VisWeek 2011]], Robert M. Kirby, Claudio T. Silva, Robert S. Laramee, and William Schroeder participated in a panel entitled "Verification in Visualization: Building a Common Culture"

Inspired by the discussions at this panel, the following people would like to organize an effort to facilitate V&V at future VisWeek submissions:

* Britta Weber
* Tim Lebo
* (feel free to add your name)

A few of us met for lunch immediately after the panel, and discussed a few points:

* SIGMOD has had something like it for 2 years, so we can borrow their model.
* Reproducibility takes (uncredited) time and effort; producing unreproducible papers is valued by the community.
* A grad student once published make files behind every published image - but stopped when he got a job.
* Publishing your code (without an established system) provides value because people grab it, use it, remember your name, and cite you in their publications.

The following people may provide useful suggestions for how to increase reproducibility within VisWeek publications:

* Claudio T. Silva - knows about SIGMOD's effort.
* "make file" SCI student - because he cared about it enough to make make files.
* [http://www.slideshare.net/anitawaard Anita de Waard]

Related work

* http://www.executablepapers.com/ by Elsevier

VisWeek V&V

2011-10-31T14:59:07Z

Lebot:

At [[VisWeek 2011]], Robert M. Kirby, Claudio T. Silva, Robert S. Laramee, and William Schroeder participated in a panel entitled "Verification in Visualization: Building a Common Culture"

Inspired by the discussions at this panel, the following people would like to organize an effort to facilitate V&V at future VisWeek submissions:

* Britta Weber
* Tim Lebo
* (feel free to add your name)

A few of us met for lunch immediately after the panel, and discussed a few points:

* SIGMOD has had something like it for 2 years, so we can borrow their model.
* Reproducibility takes (uncredited) time and effort; producing unreproducible papers is valued by the community.
* A grad student once published make files behind every published image - but stopped when he got a job.
* Publishing your code (without an established system) provides value because people grab it, use it, remember your name, and cite you in their publications.

The following people may provide useful suggestions for how to increase reproducibility within VisWeek publications:

* Claudio T. Silva - knows about SIGMOD's effort.
* "make file" SCI student - because he cared about it enough to make make files.

VisWeek V&V

2011-10-31T14:58:15Z

Lebot:

At [[VisWeek 2011]], Robert M. Kirby, Claudio T. Silva, Robert S. Laramee, and William Schroeder participated in a panel entitled "Verification in Visualization: Building a Common Culture"

Inspired by the discussions at this panel, the following people would like to organize an effort to facilitate V&V at future VisWeek submissions:

* Britta Weber
* Tim Lebo

A few of us met for lunch immediately after the panel, and discussed a few points:

* SIGMOD has had something like it for 2 years, so we can borrow their model.
* Reproducibility takes (uncredited) time and effort; producing unreproducible papers is valued by the community.
* A grad student once published make files behind every published image - but stopped when he got a job.
* Publishing your code (without an established system) provides value because people grab it, use it, remember your name, and cite you in their publications.

The following people may provide useful suggestions for how to increase reproducibility within VisWeek publications:

* Claudio T. Silva - knows about SIGMOD's effort.
* "make file" SCI student - because he cared about it enough to make make files.

VisWeek V&V

2011-10-31T14:54:38Z

Lebot: added lunch notes

At [[VisWeek 2011]], Robert M. Kirby, Claudio T. Silva, Robert S. Laramee, and William Schroeder participated in a panel entitled "Verification in Visualization: Building a Common Culture"

Inspired by the discussions at this panel, the following people would like to organize an effort to facilitate V&V at future VisWeek submissions:

* Britta Weber
* Tim Lebo

A few of us met for lunch immediately after the panel, and discussed a few points:

* SIGMOD has had something like it for 2 years, so we can borrow their model.
* Reproducibility takes (uncredited) time and effort; producing unreproducible papers is valued by the community.
* A grad student once published make files behind every published image - but stopped when he got a job.
* Publishing your code (without an established system) provides value because people grab it, use it, remember your name, and cite you in their publications.

VisWeek V&V

2011-10-31T14:48:28Z

Lebot:

At [[VisWeek 2011]], Robert M. Kirby, Claudio T. Silva, Robert S. Laramee, and William Schroeder participated in a panel entitled "Verification in Visualization: Building a Common Culture"

Inspired by the discussions at this panel, the following people would like to organize an effort to facilitate V&V at future VisWeek submissions:

* Britta Weber
* Tim Lebo

VisWeek V&V

2011-10-31T14:46:28Z

Lebot: New page: At VisWeek 2011, x chaired a panel "Verification in Visualization: Building a Common Culture" Panelists included: Robert M. Kirby, Claudio T. Silva, Robert S. Laramee, and William Sch...

At [[VisWeek 2011]], x chaired a panel "Verification in Visualization: Building a Common Culture"

Panelists included: Robert M. Kirby, Claudio T. Silva, Robert S. Laramee, and William Schroeder

Inspired by the discussions at this panel, the following people would like to organize an effort to facilitate V&V at future VisWeek submissions:

* Britta Weber
* Tim Lebo